Axminster Carpets’ plan for 400 homes can go ahead

16:46 20 January 2013

Fred Wells , founder chairman of Save Our Parkland which has lost its legal challenge to 400 homes being built at Axminster

Fred Wells , founder chairman of Save Our Parkland which has lost its legal challenge to 400 homes being built at Axminster's Cloakham Lawns. Photo by Chris Carson


Judge upholds district council’s planning approval for Cloakham Lawns housing scheme

A legal challenge to planning permission granted to Axminster Carpets for a massive housing development at the town’s Cloakham Lawns has been dismissed by a High Court Judge.

The ruling means that the consent granted by East Devon District Council (EDDC) in March 2011 was lawful and the developers can now proceed with their plans to build up to 400 homes, of which 40 per cent will be affordable.

The group who brought the Judicial Review into the council’s decision – Save Our Parkland Appeal Ltd (SOP) – must pay £10,000 towards EDDC’s costs for successfully defending the review. Their liability is limited through a Protected Costs Order, so any remaining costs, as yet not finalised, must be borne by the council tax payers of East Devon.

Commenting on the successful outcome for EDDC, Councillor Mark Williamson, Chairman of the Development Management (planning) Committee, said: “It is right that the democratic process should be followed, because the public have a right to challenge decisions if they feel they are flawed.

“In this case, the council’s action has been held up to intense legal scrutiny and has been found to be completely sound. That not only vindicates our decision but is good news in the sense that it enables much-needed housing – especially affordable homes – to be built at the eastern end of the district.”

The case turned on whether the council was right to grant planning permission for the 400 homes at a time when its existing Local Plan was in the process of being replaced by a new plan that would form part of the Local Development Framework (LDF) and whether the council gave too much weight to its emerging planning policy document.

The LDF has since reverted to the original name of Local Plan, but the new planning policy document is still in draft form and may not be adopted until 2014. The new Draft Local Plan does show a significant housing allocation in the Cloakham Lawns area of Axminster and this was already proposed when the application was considered in 2011.

However, SOP maintained that it was premature for EDDC to permit the Cloakham Lawns development because at the time of the committee decision a preferred options document was being consulted upon.

His Honour Judge Sycamore disagreed and ruled that the council had acted correctly in having one eye on the proposed allocation when it considered the application. The Judge also upheld the actions of the planning officer who recommended to councillors on the development management committee that they should grant permission.

Quoting case law in his judgment report, HH Judge Sycamore said: “If there is one principle of planning law more firmly settled than any other, it is that matters of planning judgment are within the exclusive province of the local planning authority or the Secretary of State”.

He continued: “A claim for Judicial Review will not normally merit consideration unless the overall effect of the (planning officer’s) report is to significantly mislead the committee about material matters. The author of the report is entitled to assume a knowledgeable readership and that members have particular knowledge of both the planning policy context and the local area”.

HH Judge Sycamore concluded: “Neither of the grounds of claim establishes any error of law on the part of the defendant (EDDC) in granting the outline planning permission. Accordingly, the claim is dismissed”.

Councillor Williamson added: “This ruling not only settles the future of an important development site in Axminster; it also demonstrates that the council is correct in dealing with planning applications whilst the new Local Plan is still being worked on, rather than delaying progress with vital homes until the Local Plan has been signed off.

“This ties in with the very strong guidance we are getting from central government that the housing drought has to end and that planning authorities should say yes to sustainable development”.

* SOP have indicated that they are seeking leave to appeal against the judgment.

Spokesman Paul Arnott told The Herald: “It’s disappointing but not the end.”


Other News Stories

Molly Raison at her 102nd birthday with son Nick, daughter Gaye Baulch and, at the time, youngest RNLI crew member Pete Cable. Picture: SUBMITTED

Molly instructs mourners to ‘wear something bright’ at her funeral!

Read more
Yesterday, 14:59
The patio outside a house at Farway

Cornell Construction commended for transforming an outdoor space into ‘something special’

Read more
Yesterday, 12:10

The incident happened near Hembury Fort at 10.40am.

Read more
Yesterday, 11:50
Chef Peter Gorton presents an award to Ellen Streatfeild, Wendy Williams, Helen Brandom and Jacqui Thomas. Picture by Steven Haywood

The meat producer fought off stiff competition to land two wins in the 2015 Taste of the West Product Awards.

Read more
Yesterday, 06:59
Young carer Lydia Hartnell

Axminster teenager featured in Youtube film

Read more
Wed, 17:30
Mary Bolshaw, chairman of Honiton Hospiscare Support Group, with Joyce Yates, Janet Tierney and Julie Courtney who won at a recent cake bake off competition. Ref mhh 0963-41-15AW. Picture: Alex Walton

Organisers of the event say they had hoped for a bigger turnout on the day, but were still pleased to have raised £200.

Read more
Wed, 11:35
Chairman of Honiton and District Chamber of Commerce, Colin Wright.

The group is hoping to raise in the region of £1,400 by the beginning of next month.

Read more
Wed, 09:23
Anne celebrated her birthday in style.

A Honiton woman who possesses a rich vein of farming history has celebrated her 100th birthday.

Read more
Wed, 09:06
This group haved just signed in and are ready for the Jolly Good Jaunt on Sunday.  Ref mhh 2841-41-15SH. Picture: Simon Horn

Hundreds of walkers took part in Hospiscare’s A Jolly Good Jaunt at the weekend - and are already halfway to raising the £20,000 target for Kings House Day Hospice, in Honiton.

Read more
Wed, 06:59
Doug and Joy Hull with school head pupils at the Paddington Bear lunch   Picture CHRIS CARSON

Axminster Primary Academy stages a Paddington Lunch

Read more

Local Weather

Partly Cloudy

Partly Cloudy

max temp: 14°C

min temp: 9°C

Most Read News

Great British Life

Great British Life

Useful Links

Family notices
Advertise in the paper
Submit a Story
Submit a Story
Buy Photos
Google Plus Page
Reader Travel

Family Notices 24

Read Online

Read the Midweek Herald e-edition E-edition

Find a job in Devon

Local business directory

Honiton's trusted business finder

Find planning applications