High Court rules that Honiton Town Council acted unlawfully

PUBLISHED: 15:00 11 January 2017 | UPDATED: 09:39 16 January 2017

The Honiton Beehive. Picture by Alex Walton. Ref mhh 2243-34-14AW

The Honiton Beehive. Picture by Alex Walton. Ref mhh 2243-34-14AW


Honiton Town Council acted unlawfully by imposing additional sanctions on one of its members who publicly criticised its financial dealings, the High Court has ruled.

In a letter to the press, Cllr John Taylor made a number of claims about the legality and propriety of a loan obtained by the council for The Beehive Community Centre.

He was particularly critical of the town clerk, Chetna Jones, who brought a complaint against him.

East Devon District Council’s standards sub-committee subsequently found him to be in breach of the council’s code of conduct.

But when the town council later imposed further sanctions, he applied for a judicial review, claiming they were wrong to do so.

Now High Court Judge Mr Justice Edis has ruled in his favour.

He said that in applying additional sanctions ‘over and above those recommended by East Devon District Council’, Honiton Town Council acted unlawfully.

But he continued: “The decision of East Devon District Council as to Cllr John Taylor being in breach and the sanctions it recommended was lawful.”

Mr Justice Edis concluded this after considering with some care whether he should make any order at all in the case and whether he should consider the questions raised by the parties since they were academic because the decision had been withdrawn, several times.

The summary continued: “It must be remembered that Honiton is under the statutory duty to maintain high standards of conduct. The existence of a code of conduct is regarded by Parliament as an important aspect of the maintenance of standards. It appears to me to be proportionate to a significant breach of it for a relevant authority to require the person in breach to be trained in its meaning and application. There is no point in having a code of conduct if members of the authority are not aware of its meaning and effect and where a member has demonstrated by his conduct that this is the case, a reasonable amount of training appears to be a sensible measure. A local authority should be able to require its members to undertake training which is designed to enable them to fulfil their public functions safely and effectively.

“It was reasonably open to the decision-maker to conclude that this was a serious breach of the code. There is no finding as to the claimant’s motives and it may be that he acted in good faith, believing that his statement about the town clerk was justified. However, it was not. He accused her of criminal conduct when there was not the slightest justification for doing so. This was a very serious error of judgment. Therefore, a requirement of training was proportionate.”

Honiton Town Council was due to consider its formal response to the judgment at its meeting on Monday, January 9.

Comments have been disabled on this article.

Other News Stories


County Council committee narrowly rejects calls to ask Jeremy Hunt to intervene in Honiton and Seaton inpatient beds closure plans

Read more

Hospital League of Friends is delighted with the huge amount raised at the weekly Colyford sessions

Read more

Hundreds were left disappointed after organisers pulled the plug on the event due to a stormy weather forecast for Honiton.

Read more

The supported cause is Cots for Tots, the special care baby charity for St Michael’s Hospital, Bristol. which helps in transforming the lives of sick and premature babies and their families.

Read more

Electors will go to the polls on Thursday, August 17

Read more

Video from this year’s Seaton CycleFest.

Read more

Kris West is the cream of the Lifeboat Week cake makers

Read more

A dance at Uplyme Village Hall organised by the owner of a gym and his wife has resulted in a bumper cheque for the RNLI in Lyme Regis.

Read more
Yesterday, 17:35

NHS health bosses say the closure, which is expected to last for three months, is down to combination of ‘staff vacancies and unforseen sickness absence’.

Read more
Yesterday, 15:52

David Wells and Jobe Barney thought they had disconnected the camera at the forge, near Honiton, but in fact it was recording everything they did.

Read more

Local Weather

Partly Cloudy

Partly Cloudy

max temp: 23°C

min temp: 15°C

Most Read News

Useful Links

Family notices
Advertise in the paper
Submit a Story
Submit a Story
Buy Photos
Google Plus Page
Reader Travel

Family Notices 24

Read Online

Read the Midweek Herald e-edition E-edition

Newsletter Sign Up

Sign up to receive our regular email newsletter

Local business directory

Honiton's trusted business finder


Show Job Lists

Find planning applications