Devon MP criticises retailers over loss of entry-level jobs

 <i>(Image: Newsquest)</i>
(Image: Newsquest)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

A generation of young people is being locked out of the workplace as traditional first-job opportunities disappear, a Devon MP has warned amid growing concern over rising youth unemployment.

Richard Foord, MP for Honiton and Sidmouth, criticised major retailers for replacing entry-level positions with automated systems, arguing that young people are losing valuable opportunities to gain their first experience of work.

The Liberal Democrat MP raised the issue during a parliamentary debate on Tuesday, which followed the publication of a government-backed report into youth unemployment.

The report, written by former health secretary Alan Milburn, found that almost one million people aged between 16 and 24 in the UK are not in education, employment or training (NEET), equivalent to around one in eight young people.

According to the report, eight in ten of those young people have been looking for work or opportunities for some time.

Speaking in the House of Commons, Mr Foord said: "Many young people get their first job on the checkouts.

"The boss of Next, Lord Wolfson, said that two years ago, Next received ten applications for every job vacancy, but that number has since risen to 19 applications per vacancy. He said nothing about how retailers have stripped out jobs at checkouts.

"Next made a profit of over £1 billion last year. Does the minister accept that retailers also have a responsibility to create opportunities for young people?"

Andrew Western, parliamentary under-secretary of state for work and pensions, replied: "I do accept that."

Speaking after the debate, Mr Foord said parents wanted their children to have fulfilling careers and financial independence, but argued that many young people were struggling to enter the labour market.

He said: "Parents want their children to grow up to have a fulfilling job that will afford them independence. Yet we keep hearing that young people are locked out of the job market, due to increasing automation, the growing use of artificial intelligence, and dehumanised recruitment processes that weed out applications.

"It is a bit rich for Conservative peer Lord Wolfson – the boss of Next – to get his excuses in first. Retail giants like Next, and the big supermarkets could afford to take on more young people if they were serious about it.

"Tesco made annual profits of over £3 billion in 2024/25. These retail giants do not seem interested in affording young people the chance to get early work experience, in the way that retailers used to. This is quite wrong."

Mr Milburn's report highlights the changing nature of recruitment and entry-level employment.

It states: "Entry-level roles have become less plentiful and more demanding.

"Recruitment has become more remote, more automated and less human.

"The young person who once might have walked into a shop, spoken to a manager and been given a chance in the past is now screened by a portal, a test, a recorded interview or an algorithm before anyone has looked them in the eye."

Mr Foord also argued that recent increases in business rates and National Insurance contributions had added pressure on employers, particularly smaller firms.

He said: "The increase in business rates and national insurance in the past year, have also made it tougher – especially for small businesses that are just about scraping by. These Government measures have exacerbated an already challenging job market.

"I hope that Government ministers take this very seriously. We cannot allow a generation to fall by the roadside and grow up dependent on the state."

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos