Inside The Jackdaw, Tiverton's secret new cocktail bar with a mystery

4
Skip to next photo
1/1
Show caption
1/1
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

Behind the frosted glass of what appears to be an old private detective agency, a telephone will be waiting. Pick it up, give the right code and, assuming everything checks out, a door will open into a hidden world of cocktails, Mediterranean sharing plates and monthly murder mysteries.

This is The Jackdaw, the latest creation from James Hitchin, the man behind The Peryton, and it may be his most ambitious idea yet.

Just months after James and his partner Rosie Fallows transformed the former Barley Mow in Barrington Street into one of Tiverton’s most distinctive new places to eat and drink, they have taken the keys to another premises in the town. This time it is the former Cellar at 12a Fore Street, where James is creating a speakeasy-style cocktail bar masquerading as The Jackdaw Detective Agency.

For anyone who has followed The Peryton since it opened in May, the speed of the expansion might be surprising. James admits even he had not quite anticipated how quickly the first business would take off.

“It’s been flat out really,” he said. “To be honest, we haven’t had time to catch our breath. We weren’t really ready for how busy the summer was going to be. We had a couple of record weeks over the summer.

“The response from the town has been phenomenal. Everyone’s loving it, the reviews are really solid and I’m hiring more staff as we go.”

(Image: Lewis Clarke)

The success has also changed James’s understanding of what The Peryton actually is. When it opened, his vision was primarily of a cocktail bar supported by an adventurous menu combining Japanese and Mexican influences. Instead, diners embraced the food so enthusiastically that the balance shifted.

“When we first opened it, I thought it was going to be a cocktail bar that did some food,” he said. “But actually we’re a restaurant that does some cocktails.

“We thought it was going to be a cocktail bar that did some food and really it’s come the other way round. That’s part of why we’ve taken on this new project.”

The Jackdaw will, in many ways, become the cocktail-led destination James originally imagined. He noticed customers were increasingly looking for somewhere to continue their evening after eating at The Peryton, often moving elsewhere in Tiverton or travelling further afield.

“People wanted to have a whole night,” James said. “They wanted to have a whole experience in town. There are other places in town, but they wanted somewhere where they could carry on drinking and carry on enjoying themselves.

“So what I decided was to open a place that is what The Peryton originally was going to be – a cocktail bar that does a little bit of food.”

(Image: Lewis Clarke)

The location could hardly be better suited to the idea. Hidden below street level, with little natural light and a series of atmospheric spaces, the former Cellar has previously traded under several names. Rather than fight its underground character, James intends to make it central to the experience.

There will be no conventional cocktail bar sign outside. Instead, visitors will find themselves confronted by the frontage of an old-fashioned private detective agency.

“We’re going to masquerade as a detective agency,” James said. “You go down the corridor and there’s a phone. You pick up the phone, press the button and we buzz you in. You have this secret password every month.

“The front of it will be frosted glass and it’ll say The Jackdaw Detective Agency. It won’t say cocktail bar.”

The password will change regularly, with customers able to obtain it in several ways. People dining at The Peryton will be able to receive it, while followers of The Jackdaw’s social media channels will also have opportunities to discover how to gain entry.

And for those who want to start early, the first investigation is already under way.

CASE 0001 has been placed online at www.thejackdaw.uk, challenging would-be customers to study the evidence and solve a mystery. Cracking the case will reveal what they need to gain access when The Jackdaw opens.

The JackdawThe Jackdaw (Image: The Jackdaw)

That detective theme will continue once customers make it through the door. Rather than simply being handed a conventional drinks list, visitors will receive a dossier containing a crime to investigate.

“The cocktail menu is going to be themed around a murder mystery every month,” James said. “When you come in and sit down, you’ll be given a dossier, and inside your dossier is a crime. You have a month to figure out the crime.

“There’ll be evidence photos and snapshots and things like that, and on the flip side of it will be the cocktail menu. The cocktails will be themed around that particular murder mystery.”

At the end of each month, the solution will be revealed before an entirely new investigation – and an entirely new cocktail menu – begins.

James admits that means creating an extraordinary amount of work for himself and his team.

“That’s probably going to be the biggest part of the work for us,” he said. “Every month, we’re writing a crime, writing a full cocktail menu and making them all correlate with each other.”

Helping bring that concept to life will be Tiverton bartender Mickey, who has worked with James and trained in cocktails with the team. James plans for him to step up into a management role at The Jackdaw, while the wider team will work together on the monthly menus and mysteries.

For James, the idea brings together two longstanding fascinations.

“I’m a little bit obsessed with speakeasies,” he said. “I love the idea of knowing a secret place to go to and that you’ve got this thing under your belt where you can say, ‘I’ll show you this cool thing.’

“And then I really like murder mysteries. I think those two things come together nicely. I like the idea of a detective agency because it’s quite jarring. You don’t see that traditional 1920s idea anymore, with the wingback leather chair and the private investigator.”

More importantly, he believes the concept can add something different to a night out in Tiverton.

“There’s definitely a need for somewhere else to go and drink that isn’t particularly a nightclub,” he said. “I think a lot of people are getting on the bus and going to Exeter because there’s maybe not enough of a scene to create a crawl.

“As we start to improve the offering in the town – and I mean collectively, everyone – I feel like we’re going to cultivate a scene.”

Food at The Jackdaw will be deliberately simpler than at The Peryton. James is planning Mediterranean-style sharing plates and boards, including charcuterie and meze influences, giving the kitchen freedom to move between different dishes rather than tying itself to one particular cuisine.

“The food is relatively simple,” he said. “I’m not overcomplicating it like I’ve done with The Peryton. The idea is lots of sharing boards and sharing plates.

“I know it sounds like I’m obsessed with sharing – it’s because I am. They’re going to be charcuterie-style and meze-style, and that means I can be flexible with the genre. It doesn’t have to be one particular country. It can be a little bit of this and a little bit of that.”

The lessons of The Peryton are shaping the new venue in other ways too. James had originally expected its bar to remain available for customers simply dropping in for drinks, only to find diners quickly occupying almost every available table.

At The Jackdaw, most smaller tables will therefore be kept for walk-ins, while bookings will largely be reserved for bigger groups and a proposed private area.

“We are only going to take bookings in one small area, and that’s for bigger tables,” he said. “Smaller tables – twos, threes and fours – will be walk-in only. Parties and the VIP room will be able to book online.”

The premises itself is now something of a blank canvas. James says there are no major structural works required, but the interior will be refined to create several distinct spaces. A vaulted area at the back is earmarked as a more private room, while the main bar will have space for DJs and acoustic performances.

“It’s actually an amazing space,” he said. “There’s only one window and it’s very small and right at the top of the stairs, so what I’m not envisioning is somewhere that’s going to be open during the day. No one is going to go down into a cellar and want a drink there during that time.

“The bit at the back has a vaulted ceiling that we need to turn into a bit of a VIP room, and in the main part of the bar we need to put space in so we can have DJs and acoustic nights and create a nice atmosphere.”

James hopes The Jackdaw will open in November. His ideal target is the beginning of the month, although he believes the middle of November may prove more realistic, with the overriding aim of having the doors open well before Christmas.

Taking on another venue at a time when the hospitality trade continues to face enormous pressure is not lost on him.

“People must think I’m mad,” he said. “In the midst of what everyone keeps referring to as hospitality being on its knees, I’m opening two different venues of quite obscure styles in a smaller town. They must think I’m crazy.”

Yet James believes changing drinking habits make distinctive experiences increasingly important. Younger customers, he argues, may not necessarily be consuming alcohol in the quantities previous generations did, but they are still going out – they are simply becoming more selective.

“Ultimately what they’re looking for is experiences,” he said. “If you try to continue to offer the same thing that you did 25 or 30 years ago, it can be the most consistent thing in the world, but if there isn’t an experience to talk about, then you don’t really offer anything.

“I do think people want experiences and I do think people want to do things that are new. That’s why we thought The Jackdaw was a really interesting project. It wasn’t just, ‘Come and sit in our bar and drink.’ It’s, ‘Here’s a mystery. Here’s something new. Here’s something to do.’

“And next month it’s completely different and you’ve got a whole new concept and menu. We really are making a nightmare for ourselves.”

Behind all the theatrical touches, hidden passwords and detective dossiers, however, is the same philosophy James brought to The Peryton. For him, memorable hospitality ultimately has very little to do with the building itself.

It is a lesson he says he repeatedly gives his staff.

“You are part of the worst day and probably the best day of some people’s lives,” James said. “You see people on their most important birthday. I’ve seen more engagements than you can ever imagine. I’ve seen 21st birthdays, first kisses and all these moments.

“But I’ve seen the worst days of people’s lives too, because they go to pubs and restaurants. They go to places where there are people.

“Hospitality isn’t built on bricks and mortar. It’s built on people. If you take the people out of it, if you take the soul out of it, all you’ve got is bricks and mortar and wooden tables.”

For James, success at The Jackdaw will therefore not simply be measured by how many people manage to crack the password, solve the crime or order another cocktail.

“Success is consistency,” he said. “It’s quality and it’s filling the gap. We opened The Peryton because there was a vacuum in Tiverton for somewhere like that. We’re opening The Jackdaw because I feel there’s a vacuum that exists for that function.

“It had to be the right product, in the right venue, at the right time.”

The keys are now in his hands. The first case is open. And somewhere behind the façade of a private detective agency on Fore Street, Tiverton’s latest mystery is beginning to take shape.

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos