Devon brewery's Panther Black IPA wins People's Choice award

The Cottage Beer Project - Dan Clayton <i>(Image: Lewis Clarke)</i>
The Cottage Beer Project - Dan Clayton (Image: Lewis Clarke)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

The Beast of Exmoor has been caught – and Devon drinkers are raising a glass to it. This particular Panther isn't prowling the moors, though. It comes in a bottle, has notes of chocolate, toffee and spice, and has just been voted the county's favourite food or drink product.

Behind the award-winning Panther Black IPA is 57-year-old Dan Clayton, who swapped a 25-year career in corporate procurement for the very different pleasures – and pressures – of running Cottage Beer Project, a tiny independent brewery near Morebath on the edge of Exmoor. His unusual dark beer has won the People's Choice 'Your Favourite Product' title at the 2026 Food Drink Devon Awards, held at Sandy Park in Exeter in October. It also received a Platinum award from the judges, adding to a growing collection of honours.

The Cottage Beer Project at the Food Drink Devon AwardsThe Cottage Beer Project at the Food Drink Devon Awards (Image: Submitted)

"It's brilliant," Dan says. "To get recognition from so many people for our beer means a lot. We knew it was a good beer because it's won Platinum awards and qualified for the national finals this year, but for other people to recognise that and take the time to vote for us was great. Claire was a bit gobsmacked on the night. She was quite stunned that we'd got the people's vote."

For Dan, the distinction between an expert panel and the drinking public makes the latest recognition particularly special. "It's not just beer judges. It's people recognising that this is a good product, a product that stands out and is worth voting for," he says. "It's easy for people to say they like something but not bother to vote. It gives me a real buzz as a brewer that people have taken that time."

Panther is a 5.5 per cent black IPA, a style that challenges what many beer drinkers expect when they see those three familiar letters. While an India pale ale is usually, well, pale, Dan's version is dark and richly layered, without losing the hoppy character associated with an IPA. Food Drink Devon describes its flavours as combining toffee, chocolate and spice with citrus and fruit aromas, balanced by bitterness and a gentle roasted character.

"It's an unusual style. People expect an IPA to be pale, don't they? So, with it being black, it's different," Dan says. "It's a very complex beer, with a lot going on. It's got a subtle roasted note, but you don't want it to be like a stout or porter. It's got a lot of the flavour and aroma you'd expect from a normal IPA. It's got rye in it, which makes it nice and smooth, and it's a bit spicy. It's my favourite beer of all the ones I make because it really is something quite different."

The Cottage Beer Project - Dan ClaytonThe Cottage Beer Project - Dan Clayton (Image: Submitted)

Getting all those flavours to work together requires a careful hand. Too much dark barley and the roasted notes can dominate; too much bitterness and the balance disappears. "You've got to get the right balance so the dark barleys play off nicely against the bitterness and aromas from the hops," Dan says. "You're using different grains to get particular caramel effects, and working out what percentages of each grain you need. Because it's a complex beer, it's almost like a complex calculation."

Remarkably, Panther did not evolve through dozens of experimental batches. Dan developed the recipe using the knowledge he had accumulated as a home brewer, then made it for the first time on his commercial equipment. "I never produced this as a home brewer," he says. "It was first produced on my commercial kit, and it's always been consistent since day one. Over the years I've learnt what works best in terms of grains and hops together. I managed to put it together without any real issues."

Perhaps the most satisfying part comes when someone tastes it without knowing what to expect. "I love seeing the reaction on people's faces," Dan says. "We used to give out samples at events before it had won awards. People would take a sip and go, 'Oh wow, that's really good.' I think they expect it to be more like a stout or porter, and it really isn't. It takes them by surprise."

The name is every bit as local as the beer itself. The legendary Beast of Exmoor has often been imagined as a mysterious big cat, and Dan has borrowed the panther for his label. Several of his other beers also take their inspiration from the surrounding landscape and wildlife. It is part of a brewery whose identity is closely tied to the place in which it was created, right down to the natural Devon water drawn from its own borehole.

But brewing was not always Dan's world. For a quarter of a century he worked as a European procurement manager, before discovering home brewing around 2016. "I was in procurement for 25 years, and it wasn't necessarily my passion," he says. "I've always loved real ale. There are so many varieties you can try and make, and I thought, let's try brewing some on a small scale and see how it goes. I found the science behind it incredibly interesting, and it just went from there."

By 2020, he could see a business taking shape. An industrial unit he had been offered that February would have meant starting on a larger scale, but he and Claire decided against it – a fortunate decision when the first Covid lockdown arrived the following month. Instead, they established Cottage Beer Project later in the year, with commercial brewing beginning in 2021. Early online orders and local deliveries helped the fledgling operation through a period when markets and fairs were largely out of reach.

The brewery's name tells its own story. "We live in a cottage, the brewery is in an outbuilding, and it's a cottage industry because it's so small," Dan says. "I didn't want to call it a brewery. I wanted something a bit unique." He was equally clear about the business he wanted to create: "A local, sustainable, ethical business producing small-scale, bottle-conditioned beers to a great quality – something that associates well with the local community and environment."

His first commercial beer was Hit for Six, a traditional English IPA of six per cent strength that had its origins in his home-brewing days. "All my friends liked it, but they liked beer because it was free at the time," he says. "It's one of those that's had its loyal following from the early days, so people come back for it regularly." The brewery has since expanded into pale ales, stouts, dark ales and seasonal releases, with its Mild Boar also picking up Gold at this year's Food Drink Devon Awards.

For a nano-brewery, however, the work extends far beyond experimenting with recipes. With two fermenters, Dan can usually brew once a week, alongside bottling, paperwork and days spent selling at markets. "There isn't a typical day," he says. "There'll be a brewing day, a bottling day, an administration day and probably two sales days. It might be a five-, six- or seven-day working week, but it's flexible. I can take the dog for a walk on Exmoor if I want to. That's part of the enjoyment – there's always something different to do."

The Cottage Beer ProjectThe Cottage Beer Project (Image: Submitted)

And the economics of making exceptional beer on a tiny scale are not always easy. "There's a lot of competition, and people can buy cheap beer from supermarkets. I'm not competing with that," Dan says. "The costs are high in brewing and the income is relatively low. You're not going to get rich brewing. They used to say that if you want a small fortune in brewing, you start with a large fortune." He adds: "I went into it with my eyes wide open. It's something I do because I enjoy it, and it gives me a different lifestyle. I'm lucky enough to be able to follow a passion and enjoy my job."

That personal connection is also why he spends so many weekends talking to customers face to face. "Being such a small business, we have to be out talking to people and selling direct," he says. "Part of going to markets and fairs is telling the story, building relationships and helping people understand what a bottle-conditioned beer is and why it's at the price it is." Alongside local stockists and events, Cottage Beer Project now offers UK-wide online orders, while brewery visits and guided tastings give curious drinkers a closer look at the process.

Sustainability is another important part of the project. The small-batch beers are vegan-friendly, the business has achieved single-use plastic-free accreditation, and it has been recognised with a Food Drink Devon Gold sustainability award. Its work with Exmoor National Park and the North Devon Biosphere reflects Dan's ambition to make beer that belongs to its landscape rather than simply borrowing its name.

The People's Choice win has already made a difference. Dan says customers have sought out Panther specifically after hearing about the award, giving the beer a noticeable boost at markets. And although 2025 was a difficult trading year, he has seen encouraging signs ahead of the busy festive season. "The markets I've done year on year have been slightly up, which is encouraging," he says. "I go into Christmas, which is our busiest time of year, with a very positive outlook."

There is more to come. A new, Exmoor-inspired beer is planned for early December, although its name remains under wraps, and Dan hopes to build awareness of the brewery beyond Devon through UK shipping. He is also continuing his own education, having recently completed a three-day Wine & Spirit Education Trust beer course that involved tasting around 24 different beers and an exam. "It's about detecting the different notes – spices, fruits, any off-flavours – and seeing if they're balanced," he says. "It's really about tasting rather than just enjoying a drink."

For anyone tempted to open a Panther, Dan has one final piece of advice: resist the urge to serve it ice-cold. He recommends around 11 to 13 degrees Celsius, closer to traditional cellar temperature, to bring out the flavours and aromas. And after years spent perfecting the calculations, attending markets and explaining his beers one bottle at a time, he is discovering that a little recognition from the people drinking them can be just as rewarding as anything in the glass.

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos