'Heads should roll' as judge criticises EDDC

PUBLISHED: 11:30 17 May 2015 | UPDATED: 16:19 05 June 2015

EDDC's Knowle HQ. Ref shs 7705-15-12SH Picture: Simon Horn

EDDC's Knowle HQ. Ref shs 7705-15-12SH Picture: Simon Horn


Council branded 'discourteous and unhelpful' in tribunal verdict into headquarters secrecy row.

Campaigners have called for staff to ‘consider their positions’ after East Devon District Council (EDDC) blew £11,000 of tax-payers’ cash in a failed secrecy row.

A judge blasted EDDC as ‘discourteous and unhelpful’ after rejecting its appeal for confidential documents, relating to its controversial relocation project, to remain private.

The verdict brings to a close an eight-month legal battle - which began when a Sidmouth resident lodged a Freedom of Information (FoI) request and ended up in court.

EDDC spent a five-figure sum on lawyers’ fees.

The judge in the case took the ‘unusual and unfortunate’ step of criticising the council’s conduct during the process, which he said had delayed the tribunal’s decision by six months.

EDDC says it is now reviewing all relevant documents with a view to publishing those that the court has called for - plus any others that are ‘no longer commercially sensitive’.

However, the ruling comes too late to influence the decision on the relocation project, which was given the final go-ahead by councillors on March 25.

Campaigners from Save Our Sidmouth (SOS) welcomed the verdict, saying that council personnel involved should be ‘considering their positions’.

Sidmouth resident Jeremy Woodward originally lodged an FoI request for the relocation documents.

He said this week that the council had ‘brought itself in to disrepute’ with its ‘shambolic’ handling of his initial request, and the subsequent appeal.

Mr Woodward’s original FoI in February 2013 asked the council to release reports containing background information about the authority’s proposed relocation from Sidmouth.

His request was refused, with the authority arguing the documents were exempt from FoI rules.

However, the Information Commissioner’s Office ruled that seven reports should be released.

EDDC appealed the decision and a hearing took place at Exeter Magistrates’ Court in August 2014.

In the verdict published this week, Judge Brian Kennedy QC said the appeal ‘could and should’ have been completed in August, had EDDC ‘discharged its responsibilities properly’.

He added: “Correspondence on behalf of the council, rather than ensuring the tribunal was assisted in its function, was at times discourteous and unhelpful, including the statement that we had the most legible copies [of the disputed information] possible. A statement which was clearly inaccurate as, subsequently, we have been provided with perfectly legible documents.”

SOS said in a statement: “Throughout our campaign against the relocation, we have continually been battling EDDC errors, deliberate obfuscations and a refusal to examine rational options. We fully endorse the judge’s conclusions on EDDC’s behaviour, not only related to this particular event. We believe that EDDC personnel involved should be considering their positions.”

An EDDC spokesman said: “It’s quite clear that lessons need to be taken away from this experience. These lessons can and will be learned and steps will be taken at the very earliest opportunity to look at the conduct of our appeal.

“In any form of partnership working, each partner has to respect the commercial sensitivity of certain information.

“This can be a difficult balancing act and we have to reflect on the fact that, in this case, we may not have got that balance right.”

More Election News

East Devon election candidates have weighed in on one of the most polarising debates at this time of year - what really is the best Christmas film?

Read more
East Devon
Tue, 13:21

Conservative Party candidate Simon Jupp has pulled out of a hustings event in Sidmouth.

Read more
Mon, 17:00

Investment in broadband and public transport as well as care and community service will help keep East Devon communities connected.

Read more
East Devon
Sunday, December 1, 2019

Ofsted reform and increased funding are among the promises being made on education by candidates ahead of the election.

Read more
East Devon
Wednesday, November 27, 2019

Cheaper public transport, increased taxes on fossil fuels, investment in green energy and amendments to planning laws are among suggestions to tackle climate change.

Read more
Tuesday, November 26, 2019

Extra investment in mental health services and nursing bursaries in East Devon are among the promises being made ahead of the elections.

Read more
East Devon
Friday, November 8, 2019

'I'm in it to win it' - Labour's East Devon candidate is confident of become the region's next MP.

Read more
East Devon

Local Weather

Partly Cloudy

Partly Cloudy

max temp: 11°C

min temp: 7°C

Most Read News

Useful Links

Family notices
Advertise in the paper
Submit a Story
Submit a Story
Buy Photos
Google Plus Page
Family Notices 24

Read Online

Read the Midweek Herald e-edition E-edition

Most Read

Latest from the Midweek Herald

Hot Jobs

Show Job Lists