Superman was a fake

PUBLISHED: 10:22 30 November 2011

Archant

Woman in court.

AN Axminster woman who ran a company selling fake goods has been ordered to do unpaid work for the community – and pay almost £15,000 in costs.

Natalie McCarthy, 47, of Waggs Plot, Colston, admitted eight offences under the Trade Marks Act at Exeter Crown Court last week.

The mother-of-three had been the main force behind a successful eBay business called Honeytoast UK, importing cheap gift items from the Philippines for children’s parties.

The items bore a number of well known children’s characters, including Superman, Winnie the Pooh and various Disney characters. Many of them - up to 97 per cent of those seized - were counterfeit, bearing the trade marks of established companies.

McCarthy’s husband, James, accepted a Simple Caution on one charge on the basis that his role in the partnership had been largely a silent one.

The McCarthys have made a contribution to Devon County Council’s costs of £10,000 and Mrs McCarthy was ordered to pay the remaining £4,824.14.

There was a forfeiture order for the 10,000 plus seized items which also represent a financial loss to them of over £10,000. The judge considered that the custody threshold had been met but took into account the financial penalties involved and the previous good character and sentenced Mrs McCarthy to a 40 hours Community Service Order.

The Judge commented that she did not make sufficient checks on the products and that the outcome should have a deterrent effect on others.

After the hearing Devon County Council officials issued the following warning to would-be traders: “People who intend to import goods for resale should consider approaching their local trading standards for advice on legal requirements, particularly when the manufacturing base is outside the EU.”


If you value what this story gives you, please consider supporting the Midweek Herald. Click the link in the orange box above for details.

Become a supporter

This newspaper has been a central part of community life for many years. Our industry faces testing times, which is why we're asking for your support. Every contribution will help us continue to produce local journalism that makes a measurable difference to our community.

Latest from the Midweek Herald