Warning to 'white van man' over blind spots
PUBLISHED: 14:08 17 September 2009 | UPDATED: 00:12 16 June 2010
A warning goes out today to Britain s white van man as a shocking new report reveals that many popular van designs have dangerous blind spots, caused by the A-pillars on either side of the windscreen...
A warning goes out today to Britain's 'white van man' as a shocking new report reveals that many popular van designs have dangerous blind spots, caused by the A-pillars on either side of the windscreen, which are wide enough to hide a cyclist, motorbike or group of people from view.
Leading consumer service brand Autoglass(r) commissioned MIRA (formerly the Motor Industry Research Association) to test 'driver vision' in different makes and models of modern vans and cars. The tests included a calculation of the A-pillar blind spot, or 'A- spot' - the width of objects obscured from a driver's vision at 23 metres; the stopping distance required when travelling at 30mph.
With over 1,800 cyclists and motorcyclists involved in accidents with vans each year² and at a time when many parents are hiring vans to take their children off to university or college, Autoglass(r) is keen to warn of the potentially fatal blind spot problem.
The Ford Transit revealed appalling results with an A-Spot measuring 6.4 metres - three times larger than the best performing saloon car, the Mercedes C Class - and capable of hiding two full sized motorcycles or a group of cyclists from the driver's view.
The Mercedes Benz Sprinter and Vito also displayed shocking marks with A-Spots of 6.3 metres and 6.2 metres, capable of hiding a group of 15 children. Even the small models didn't escape the horrendous blind spot with the VW Caddy having an A-Spot of 4.2 metres.
Autoglass(r) undertook the new research as part of its ongoing commitment to road safety. In 2006 the windscreen specialist first commissioned A-Pillar testing in a number of vehicles, revealing worrying blind spot results. Encouragingly, recent test results show that manufacturers have addressed the thickening A-Pillar in newer models - the windscreen posts on the VW Golf, Ford Mondeo, Ford Focus, Toyota Prius and Vauxhall Vectra are all actually thinner now than on their 2006 predecessor. The windscreen specialist is now calling for the Government to review manufacturing guidelines on vans.
The leading cause of fatal, serious and slight crashes on UK roads is drivers 'failing to look properly³' with 49,533 (35%) accidents in 2007. Autoglass(r) has teamed up with leading road safety organisation RoadSafe and national cycling organisation CTC to warn drivers that there could be a high price to pay for failing to check their A-Pillar blind spot.
Nigel Doggett, managing director at Autoglass(r) said, "We are encouraged to see that the research we carried out in 2006 has had an impact on manufacturers and that four out of the five cars tested now have thinner A-pillars.
"As a large van fleet operator we tested vans this time to highlight that their A-pillars can have a detrimental effect on the driver's vision, by creating blind spots that pose a real threat to other road users. Apart from the thousands of everyday van drivers in the UK, for many motorists, getting into a van may be something they do only once or twice a year, when moving house, or going off to university, so it is vital that every driver takes extra care to ensure they've seen all of the hazards around them before setting off.
"We will be communicating the A-Spot road safety message to our own internal fleet of van drivers through a road safety programme and all drivers will be issued with advice. We would also like to see the Driving Standards Agency provide guidance for driving instructors on educating new drivers about the A-Spot, the message is clear - drivers must check their A-Spot in every vehicle, or risk paying a high price."
Results from the Department for Transport show that in 2008 16,297 cyclists were injured on the roads4, so the A-Pillar blind spot is of great concern to the CTC. Policy coordinator Chris Peck,
comments: "Drivers must take extra care to look in their blind spots because a cyclist can easily be hidden from view. It is the duty of the driver to make sure they have seen everything and everyone around them - especially cyclists and pedestrians. The new research highlights the increasing danger of the A-Pillar blind spot, therefore it is vital that motorists know that they must check all their blind spots when maneuvering."
Adrian Walsh, director of RoadSafe, adds: "Drivers have a responsibility to familiarise themselves with their vehicle and must ensure their own safety, that of their passengers and, most importantly, other road users, particularly cyclists and motorcyclists; looking out for both rear and forward facing blind spots. The latest report shows that A-Pillar blind spots need to be acknowledged in every vehicle, and the guidance offered by Autoglass(r) should be noted."
For more information and to watch the A-Pillar safety video visit www.autoglassnews.co.uk
Autoglass(r) is the UK's leading vehicle glass repair and replacement service, with 109 branches nationwide and 1,300 mobile service units. For details of your nearest centre call 0800 36 36
36 or visit www.autoglass.co.uk.
Notes to Editors
For a full copy of the report and A-Pillar photography please contact Katie McDermott on 0121 711 5000 or email katie@bright- consultancy.co.uk
Research Methodology and Highlights
A-Pillar obscuration levels were tested on a cross section of popular new vans and cars. This included a calculation of the A- Spot - the width obscured from a driver's vision at 23 metres; the stopping distance required when travelling at 30mph.
Tests were completed on seven popular vans, A-Spot measurement were as follows:
1 Ford Transit 6.41m
2 Mercedes Benz 6.38m
3 Mercedes Benz 6.24m
4 Citroen Berlingo 5.94m
5 Ford Transit 5.93m
6 VW Transporter 5.51m
7 VW Caddy 4.29m
The A-Spot measurements for all twenty seven vehicles in full were as follows:
1 Peugeot 308CC 6.42m
2 Ford Transit 6.41m
3 Mercedes Benz 6.38m
4 Mercedes Benz 6.24m
5 Fiat Bravo 6.11m
6 Nissan X-Trail 6.08m
7 Citreon Berlingo 5.94m
8 Ford Transit 5.93m
9 Suzuki Alto 5.89m
10 BMW Z4 5.66m
11 Chevrolet Captiva 5.65m
12 VW Transporter 5.51m
13 Audi A4 5.32m
14 Vauxhall Vectra 5.15m
15 Hyundai i20 5.13m
16 Toyota Prius 4.92m
17 Mitusbishi i 4.83m
18 BMW 1 Series 4.66m
19 BMW X5 4.42m
20 VW Caddy 4.29m
21 VW Golf 4.06m
22 Ford Focus 3.39m
23 Ford Ka 3.08m
24 Ford Mondeo 2.83m
25 Toyota IQ 2.80m
26 Ford Fiesta 2.40m
27 Mercedes Benz C- 2.02m
Tests were completed on new models of six cars previously tested in 2006, new A-Spot measurement were as follows:
2006 2009 change
1 Ford Mondeo 6.20m 2.83m - 54%
2 Ford Focus 5.60m 3.39m - 39%
3 VW Golf 6.40m 4.06m - 37%
4 Vauxhall Vectra 6.20m 5.15m - 17%
5 Toyota Prius 5.70m 4.92m - 14%
6 Audi A4 3.80m 5.32m + 40%
Testing took place at MIRA during August 2009. The test method involved visibility equipment that replicates the driver's eyes and casts an image of the actual obscuration seen at the driver's eyeline onto calibrated wallboards for measurement.
Please note that all these vehicles comply with current visibility legislation.